Tomer C. Henryk Ryterski, Adv.Tomer C. Henryk Ryterski, Adv. · 30+ years in commercial crisis & dispute resolution · Contact us

A negative review, a customer-group message or a competitor’s accusation can affect a business. Before filing a defamation claim in Israel, identify exactly what was published, whom it referred to, how it was distributed and what response would protect the business without spreading the allegation further.

Not every negative review supports a successful claim. The Prohibition of Defamation Law protects individuals and corporations, while also recognising permitted publications and defences. Neither falsity nor an intention to harm is an automatic requirement for every civil claim; the publication, its meaning and the available defences must be examined. Businesses setting up a company in Israel should include lawful handling of complaints and public responses in their procedures.

Start with the Publication and the Business Goal

Keep the complete publication, its URL, date, account details and surrounding conversation before it changes. Preserve relevant contracts, customer-service records and evidence of any lost business. A fall in sales after a post does not, by itself, prove that the post caused the loss.

Civil and Criminal Proceedings Are Different

Section 7 addresses civil liability, while section 6 creates a criminal offence with additional requirements, including intent to harm and publication to at least two people other than the injured person. Section 8 permits a private criminal complaint. Select the procedure and remedy on legal advice rather than treating a criminal complaint as an ordinary debt-collection tool.

Comparison Between Proceedings

Feature Civil Proceeding Criminal Proceeding
Primary Goal Compensation and other available civil remedies Criminal responsibility and punishment; the law also provides for specified compensation and orders
Standard of Proof Balance of probabilities, subject to the applicable legal rules Beyond a reasonable doubt
Intent to Harm Generally not required Intent to harm is a statutory element under section 6, alongside the other requirements

Four Questions Before Bringing a Civil Claim

A claim requires a review of the statute and the evidence. The following questions organise that review; they are not a substitute for identifying the relevant elements, permitted publications and defences:

  1. Publication: section 2 covers several forms of communication. For writing, it also addresses circumstances in which the text could have reached someone other than the injured person. Do not assume a read receipt is always required.

  2. Defamatory meaning: assess the full content and context against section 1, including potential harm to the person’s business, occupation or profession. A statement need not cause proven financial loss to raise the issue.

  3. Identification: under section 3, the reference to the claimant can be implied by the publication or outside circumstances. The claimant need not always be named expressly.

  4. Defences and permitted publications: examine sections 13 to 16 before deciding whether an actionable claim remains. A label such as “in my opinion” does not settle the question by itself.

Disputes involving restricted accounts or banking disputes can include sensitive information. A public accusation against a bank should be checked against the documents, the person responsible and the available legal basis. Our Guide on Suing Banks provides related background; a banking error does not automatically prove defamation.

Defense Lines: Truth and Good Faith

Section 14 requires both truth and public interest for the truth-of-publication defence, while addressing immaterial incidental inaccuracies. Good faith under section 15 requires one of the listed circumstances; section 16 sets relevant presumptions. A complaint to an authorised body is not equivalent to distributing the complaint to customers: section 15(8) does not itself protect that separate republication.

Managing Defamation Claims in the Digital Arena

In Shaul v. Nidaily Communications, RA 1239/19, the Supreme Court distinguished a Facebook share, which can be publication, from a like in that setting. This does not make every sharer automatically liable for the same sum as the original author. A group administrator’s responsibility also requires its own legal and factual basis; the role alone does not decide liability. If the dispute affects debt negotiations, our Winning Negotiations Guide for Debt Settlement discusses that separate commercial process.

What is a Reputation Worth?

Section 7A allows discretionary compensation without proof of damage up to the statutory indexed ceiling. The base sum is NIS 50,000, updated on the 16th of each month by the statutory CPI mechanism using September 1998 as the base index. Where intent to harm is proved, the court may award up to twice the indexed amount. The law bars more than one such award for the same defamation; do not mechanically multiply a ceiling by screenshots, recipients or shares. A claim for actual loss needs evidence of the loss and its connection to the publication. Our Foreign Investor’s Guide to Buying Property concerns a separate property-law subject, not the defamation compensation rules.


Choose a clear objective: removal, correction, stopping distribution, compensation or a negotiated outcome. Section 9 provides for specified orders, including correction, denial or publication of the judgment; it does not make every requested remedy automatic. RNC can review the publication, possible defences and evidence. connect with our strategic legal team for a consultation with the complete material and any approaching deadline.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and their application depend on the facts and jurisdiction and may change. Although we aim to keep this information accurate and current, we do not guarantee that it is complete or up to date. The article may contain omissions or errors. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with RNC Group. Before making a decision or taking action, seek advice from a qualified lawyer in the relevant jurisdiction.

Tomer C. Henryk Ryterski
Tomer C. Henryk Ryterski, Adv.Founder and manager of RNC Group, with over 30 years of experience in complex commercial crisis management and dispute resolution. Facing a commercial dispute or crisis? Contact RNC Group.About · All articles by Tomer
INK

Contact Us